A financial advisory firm’s succession plan is designed to gradually transition ownership, leadership, and growth responsibilities to the next generation of advisors. The goal is the sustainability of the firm, accomplished through a plan that coordinates the changing roles of the founder(s) and the successor team over many years.
Selling equity in the business in a series of steps, or “tranches,” gives both the founder and the next generation of owners time to manage the transition wisely and prepare for the changes to come. The transfer of ownership from the founders (G1s) to the second and third generations of owners (G2s and G3s) starts with tranche 1. Tranche 1 is usually a sale of 10% to 20% of ownership to the next generation. Often called the “incubator” stage, it allows all parties to test the waters and prepare the business structure for the journey ahead.
TRANCHE: Tranche is a French word meaning slice or portion; it’s the term used for each sale of shares.
The second step, tranche 2, can include another sale of 10% to 20%, with G1 retaining the majority ownership position. How much equity is sold, and how often, depends on G1’s timeline. A founder exiting in 30 years can sell shares more slowly than an advisor with a six-year timeline. The tranche system, selling to G2s and eventually G3s, not only widens the ownership base but also provides a strong continuity plan in case of death or disability.
Not everyone in Tranche 1 will necessarily move into Tranche 2. The deal terms and percentage of ownership sold do not have to be the same from tranche to tranche. One thing is vital, however: the readiness of the G1s, the G2s, and the business itself. All need to be in alignment for the plan to succeed.
The best way to achieve this alignment over the course of the first tranche is to support open communication and the free flow of accurate, reliable information. Day-to-day conversations and regular meetings to review the progress of both the firm and the new owners are key.
As owners set goals and plan for the next tranche, here are some considerations for each party’s unique position and role in the plan.
The second buy-in is key because this is where G2s start to shoulder more risk and responsibility.
HOURS: A decrease in ownership percentage should correlate with a decrease in overall hours worked, which is part of preparing G2s and G3s to take over one day. A founder may decide to take Fridays off or one week off a month. This is a good opportunity to see how the firm runs with the G2s in place and to help them hone their skills as owners.
TRAINING: Founders will want to nurture G2 growth and monitor their progress. That means taking the time to show them the ropes and giving them the opportunity to make mistakes in a safe environment. Watching how G2s handle those mistakes and face challenges creates valuable teaching opportunities.
TIMING: Founders should think about their exit timeline, whether it’s more than a decade away or within the next few years. Either way, they’ll need to consider the pace of the succession plan and adjust gradually to stay aligned with their long-term financial and transition goals. Goals change, and the tranches of a plan can and should be adjusted accordingly, whether that means overlapping tranches or accelerating the plan.
FINANCES: Founders should assess their personal and business finances and how they factor into the succession plan. How much longer do they want to work? Do they enjoy having business partners and next-generation owners to work with? What does retirement mean to them? This conversation should include a spouse and might include other family members. Founders should also consider how financing for subsequent tranches may need to change to meet their personal income goals.
MENTAL READINESS: Founders should think ahead about what they want to do next. Whether a founder plans to leave the business entirely one day or stay on in an advisory role, having post-work plans in mind makes the ongoing transfer of ownership, leadership, and management easier.
As next-generation owners continue along the ownership path, their roles will shift. They may earn new titles, their workloads will most likely increase, and G1’s responsibilities will gradually become theirs. They’ll also earn money based on the company’s profitability and have a say in shaping the future of the business.
RESPONSIBILITY: Increased ownership brings increased responsibility. This could include managing other staff, providing input on business decisions, and bringing new ideas to the table. Regular performance reviews give next-generation owners and their fellow owners an opportunity to gauge progress. G2s and G3s should also consider how they’re personally handling the added responsibilities and make sure they’re ready to put in the time needed to grow and improve the business and to accommodate G1’s gradually diminishing role.
PRODUCTION: Next-generation owners should review production goals, both their own and those of the business. Are those goals still appropriate given the length of the anticipated succession plan, the level of profitability, and the financial needs of the ownership team? Are they being met, exceeded, or missed? G2s and G3s should also look ahead to how their goals will evolve as they take on more responsibility and a larger ownership stake.
SKILLS/PROFESSIONAL GROWTH: It’s important for next-generation owners to consider the skills they’ve acquired over the years of the first tranche. How has their product knowledge improved? Are they comfortable reading the business’s financial statements? Continuing education, extra courses, and new designations are all signs of growth. Soft skills matter too, such as the ability to lead client meetings, recruit and train new talent, and manage conflict when staff members don’t work well together.
PERSONAL GOALS: As tranche 1 progresses, next-generation owners should make sure their ownership in the firm adequately supports their business, family, and personal goals. Do they want to earn more money? Do they want more control over their time and workweek demands? Do they aspire to more ownership and control? G2s and G3s should continue communicating their goals and needs with stakeholders, since business and financial goals, and risks, change with increased ownership.
RISK: For some people, investing in the firm is an exciting opportunity to contribute their passion to something they can help grow and that can provide a substantial financial reward. But the investment carries risk, and not everyone may be ready to increase their risk exposure. Each tranche tends to gradually increase the level of risk for G2 and G3 advisors, so it pays to ask questions and learn more about the process.
VISION: Next-generation owners should share with the founders what they see as the future of the business and the industry, considering every aspect of the business: regulatory structure, entity structure, the ownership team, staffing, compensation, office location, and competition. New owners often revitalize and reenergize a firm, and their enthusiasm and passion are an important asset to the ownership team. In 10 years, the business is likely to look very different, so it’s best to think this through and prepare well ahead of time.
OWNERSHIP MENTALITY: Next-generation owners, producers and non-producers alike, should consider how they’ve worked to decrease expenses and increase revenue. Have they introduced new technology, helped diversify the income stream, tightened daily procedures, or helped the company go green? Strategies that reduce overhead and improve operations show a commitment to the bottom line and the overall growth of the business, all part of being an owner.
Transferring a business takes a great deal of planning, hard work, and continual adjustment. As G1 and G2 owners collectively prepare for the next tranche, they should also take time to review the business itself.
GROWTH: Owners should check the overall health of the company, using annual valuation and benchmarking reports to analyze growth in revenue, AUM, and clients, and consider whether that growth supports moving forward with the next tranche.
CLIENTS: As more responsibilities shift to G2s, owners should look at how clients are accepting the new roles of next-generation advisors. Introducing younger advisors into client meetings, and letting them take the lead on certain projects, boosts visibility and client trust.
LONG-TERM VISION: It’s never too early to start productive conversations with G3s. If the firm has yet to identify those who might shape into long-term leaders, G2s can help lead that path or identify appropriate younger advisors.
When considering Tranche 2, owners aren’t limited to the type of financing used in Tranche 1, which is most often a seller-financed (G1), profit-based soft note with a stock pledge as collateral. G2s pay back the note using the profit distributions they receive.
Some Tranche 2 sales switch to fixed payments, usually made monthly or quarterly, which is less risky for the lender. Another option is bank financing, which is increasingly available for internal share purchases. And when it’s time for G1 to fully exit the business, SBA lending can be used for a full buyout of the founding owner.
Learn more in Lending for Successors: What Advisors Need to Know.
The overall goal of a succession plan is to create a multi-generational, sustainable firm that will continue to care for generations of clients. The tranche system allows for the gradual, incremental transfer of ownership and preserves room to assess and adjust the overall plan as needed. Not every next-generation owner will move from tranche 1 to tranche 2, but regular communication among owners, future owners, and other key employees allows the plan to evolve continually and gives it the best chance of success.
If you’re thinking it’s time to build a tranche plan for your firm, the consultants at FP Transitions can help. Schedule a consult today.